By Gregg Kell, Founder and Editor, Spotlight on Startups | November 2026
How to choose an AEO agency in 2027 comes down to one test. Getting named by AI assistants takes two jobs, and a provider must show how it handles both. Job one is a website AI can read. Job two is mentions on websites the company does not own.
The second job carries real weight. Ahrefs studied 75,000 brands and found that web mentions correlated with AI visibility at 0.66 to 0.71. Spotlight on Startups, the Earned Media Platform for B2B Founders, wrote the 12 questions below for founders about to sign a 2027 contract.
One disclosure belongs here. I am also the CEO of Kell Web Solutions, which sells Answer Engine Optimization services as Kell Solutions. That makes it one of the firms this guide tells readers to question. Put the same 12 questions to it. This guide lists no prices. All figures are current as of November 2026.
How to choose an AEO agency in 2027: the short answer
- Two jobs. A readable website and outside mentions. Few providers do both well.
- 12 questions. Three each on website work, outside mentions, measurement and contract terms.
- Zero guarantees. Google says no one can guarantee a top ranking, and the same holds for AI answers.
- One scorecard. Ask every provider the same questions and compare the answers side by side.
- One early check. Record what AI assistants say about the company today, before any provider starts.
What an AEO agency does, and the two jobs behind AI search visibility
Answer Engine Optimization, or AEO, is the work of getting a company named and described correctly by AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews. Some firms call the same work GEO.
Job one is the website. AI assistants have to be able to reach the site, read it and understand what the company does.
Job two is everything off the website. AI assistants lean on what other sources say about a company. Ahrefs found that mentions across the web tracked with AI visibility more closely than any other factor it tested. Muck Rack reported, as covered by Unite.AI, that 84 percent of the AI citations it analyzed came from earned media and 0.3 percent from paid placements. Muck Rack sells PR software.
A company with a perfect website and no outside mentions is easy to read and easy to ignore. Our guide on why ChatGPT recommends competitors explains that gap.
SEO agency, PR agency or AEO agency: who covers which job
Each type of provider tends to cover one job better than the other. The table shows where to press hardest.
These are tendencies. Plenty of firms break the pattern, which is why the questions matter more than the label on the door. We compare the provider types in detail in earned media platform vs SEO agency vs AEO agency and earned media vs PR agency. Our guides to AEO vs SEO and digital PR strategy cover the two disciplines.
Questions to ask an AEO agency about website work
1. Can AI assistants read our website today, and how will you check?
A site that blocks AI crawlers cannot be read, and the block is not always a choice. Cloudflare offers settings that turn AI crawlers away. Hasdata tested the top 10,000 websites and found that 7.9 percent blocked OpenAI’s GPTBot in their robots.txt file. It also found 115 sites that blocked GPTBot at the firewall with no such rule on file.
Good answer: the provider checks crawler access first and shows the results.
Red flag: the provider has never looked, or cannot explain how it would.
2. Which website changes will you recommend, and what evidence supports each one?
Some popular tactics have weak evidence. Ahrefs tracked 1,885 pages that added schema markup, a kind of labeling code. Citations did not rise on any AI platform it measured. Ahrefs notes that every page in the test was already being cited, so the result may not apply to new pages.
A file called llms.txt has a similar record. An SE Ranking analysis of 300,000 domains, reported by Search Engine Journal, found no measurable link between the file and AI citations. Google says its AI features need nothing special beyond a page that is indexed and eligible to show in Search.
Good answer: each recommendation comes with a reason and a source. Schema and similar work may still be worth doing for other reasons, and a good provider says which.
Red flag: a special file or block of code is sold as the main lever.
3. Who makes the changes to our website?
Some providers edit the site. Others deliver recommendations and leave the edits to the client. Either can work. Trouble starts when nobody has agreed which it is.
Good answer: the contract names who does the work and what access the provider needs.
Red flag: the provider asks for full access to the site and cannot say why.
Questions to ask an AEO agency about outside mentions
4. How will you earn mentions on websites we do not own?
This question separates the two jobs. A provider that only edits the client’s own site is doing half the work. The other half is coverage, interviews, reviews and quotes in places a buyer and an AI assistant already trust.
Good answer: a named method, such as pitching reporters or placing expert commentary, with examples from past clients.
Red flag: the answer returns to blog posts on the client’s own website. Ask who covers the rest.
5. Are any placements paid, and will readers be told?
Paid placements are legal and sometimes useful. They are a different product from earned coverage, and Muck Rack’s figures suggest AI assistants cite them far less often.
Good answer: paid items are listed separately, priced separately and labeled as sponsored where they appear.
Red flag: a guaranteed article in a named outlet. Coverage that can be guaranteed has usually been bought.
6. Who writes the content, and who checks the facts?
AI assistants repeat what they find. A wrong figure in an article can come back later as a wrong fact in an AI answer. Our guide on correcting what ChatGPT gets wrong shows how slow the cleanup can be.
Good answer: a named writer, a review step and the client’s approval before anything is published.
Red flag: content produced in bulk by AI with no person checking it.
Questions to ask an AEO agency about measurement
7. What will you report each month, and can I see a sample?
Measurement is the weak point of the whole field. NP Digital surveyed 812 marketers and found that only 2 percent could connect AI visibility to revenue. AMEC, the international measurement association, advises against relying on a single score or a single tool.
Good answer: a real report from a current client, with names removed, showing several measures over time.
Red flag: one visibility score with no explanation of how it is calculated. HubSpot’s AEO cost guide flags the same warning sign.
8. How do you handle answers that change from one run to the next?
AI answers are not stable. SparkToro ran 2,961 tests and found the same list of brands came back less than once in 100 tries. SISTRIX found that ChatGPT Search replaced 74 percent of its sources from week to week.
Good answer: each question is asked many times, and the report shows how often the company appears.
How to compare AEO agency proposals
Comparing AEO agency proposals is easier with a fixed routine.
- Send the 12 questions in writing before the first call.
- Ask each provider which of the two jobs it does not do.
- Ask for one client reference in a similar business.
- Line up the answers in the scorecard and compare them row by row.
- Read the contract for the three items in questions 10 to 12.
The second step tells the most. A provider that names its limits is easier to trust than one that claims to do everything. If one provider covers only one job, plan who will cover the other.
Keep notes on how each provider treats the questions. A provider that answers in writing, on time and without pressure is showing how it will behave as a partner. One that dodges a question before the sale will not get clearer after it.
When not to hire an AEO agency yet
Hiring an AEO agency is not always the right first step. Three situations call for waiting.
- The company has no baseline. Run the check first. It takes an afternoon and costs nothing.
- The company cannot say in one sentence what it does and for whom. No provider can fix that from outside.
- The company has no outside mentions at all. Some can be earned without an agency.
Waiting is not the same as doing nothing. Each of the three gaps can be closed in a few weeks. Closing them first makes any later proposal easier to judge.
Our guide to press coverage without a PR agency lists five ways to earn mentions. Our guide on getting recommended by ChatGPT covers the basics a founder can handle alone. Our review of AI visibility tools explains what the software can and cannot do.
Where Spotlight on Startups fits
Spotlight on Startups is the Earned Media Platform for B2B Founders, a journalist-authored publication that publishes reported founder features structured so ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, and Google AI Overviews can find, understand, and cite them. I launched it in 2025.
It is not an agency, and it covers one small part of job two. A feature is one outside mention. It costs nothing. The process is a 10 minute Zoom call and five written questions. A writer reports the story, the founder is a source, and the publication controls the final copy.
See how the free founder spotlight works, the Get Featured page and our overview of earned, paid and owned media.
Where Kell Solutions fits
Kell Solutions is the affiliated company named in the disclosure above. Its services are an AI Crawler Access Setup, Signal AEO, Signal Authority and AEO Elite. Kell Solutions writes the content and delivers recommendations, and the client’s own team makes the changes to its website. Kell Solutions does not pitch journalists.
Those two limits are the kind of answer questions 3 and 4 are meant to draw out. Scope and pricing are on KellSolutions.com. A founder feature is never conditioned on buying anything.
How to choose an AEO agency in 2027: frequently asked questions
How do I choose an AEO agency in 2027?
Ask every provider the same 12 questions about website work, outside mentions, measurement and contract terms. Look for a provider that explains how it handles both jobs, shows a sample report, records a baseline and guarantees its work instead of results. Compare the answers side by side in a scorecard.
What does an AEO agency do?
An AEO agency helps a company get named and described correctly by AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Overviews. The work has two parts: making the company’s website easy for AI to read, and earning mentions on websites the company does not own.
Should I hire an SEO agency or a PR agency for AI search visibility?
Neither label settles it. SEO agencies are usually stronger at website work, and PR agencies at earning outside mentions. AI search visibility needs both. Ask each provider which of the two jobs it does not do, then plan who will cover the gap.
Can an AEO agency guarantee that ChatGPT will recommend my company?
No. Nobody controls what an AI assistant says, and answers change from one run to the next. SparkToro found the same list of brands came back less than once in 100 tries. A provider can guarantee its work, its schedule and its reports. Treat a guarantee of results as a red flag.
What are the red flags when hiring an AEO agency?
Watch for guaranteed rankings or citations, a single visibility score with no method behind it, a special file or code sold as the main lever, no baseline, paid placements described as earned, and a long contract with no exit. Any one of these is reason to ask harder questions.
Do I need schema markup or an llms.txt file to appear in AI answers?
The evidence so far says neither is a main lever. Ahrefs tracked 1,885 pages that added schema markup and saw no rise in AI citations. An SE Ranking analysis of 300,000 domains found no measurable link between llms.txt and citations. Google says its AI features need nothing special.
Can I improve AI search visibility without an AEO agency?
Yes, in part. A founder can check what AI assistants say today, confirm that the website does not block AI crawlers and earn outside mentions through interviews and expert commentary. An agency adds capacity and experience. It does not hold a method that is closed to everyone else.
Sources and retrieval dates
All sources below were retrieved on 16 November 2026, except the Ahrefs brand visibility, Muck Rack, SparkToro, SISTRIX and HubSpot items, which were retrieved between 14 and 16 November 2026.
- Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO? and Google Search Central, AI features and your website. Google speaks only for its own products.
- Ahrefs, We Tracked 1,885 Pages Adding Schema, May 2026, and Ahrefs, Top Brand Visibility Factors. Vendor research.
- Search Engine Journal on the SE Ranking llms.txt analysis. SE Ranking is a vendor.
- Hasdata, AI crawler block index. Vendor research. Cloudflare, Control content use for AI training, 1 July 2025.
- Unite.AI on the Muck Rack citation study, October 2026. Secondary report. Muck Rack is a vendor.
- NP Digital, how far smaller brands can trace the value of GEO. Agency research. AMEC, GEO Principles launch announcement, 20 May 2026.
- SparkToro and Gumshoe and SISTRIX, AI Citation Drift.
- HubSpot, How much does AEO cost? and WebFX, How to Choose a GEO Agency, 6 May 2026. Both sell related services.
Corrections are welcome at [email protected]. Spotlight on Startups can also be reached at (949) 354-6605.